|Guidelines Concerning the Academic Mandatum in Catholic Universities (Canon 812)
Issued by NCCB/USCC, June 15, 2001
Copyright © 2001, United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, Inc. All rights reserved.
Approved by the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops
In December 2000 the NCCB Ad Hoc Committee on the Mandatum sent a draft copy of these guidelines to all bishops for their use in conversations on the local level with theologians. The final draft entitled Guidelines Concerning the Academic Mandatum in Catholic Universities was discussed and accepted for publication by the general membership at its June 2001 General Meeting. The accepted guidelines have been authorized for publication by the undersigned.
Msgr. William P. Fay
Copyright © 2001, United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, Inc., Washington, D.C. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the copyright holder.
To order Guidelines Concerning the Academic Mandatum in Catholic Universities in its official published format, contact USCCB Publishing Services, 800-235-8722 (in the Washington metropolitan area or from outside the United States, 202-722-8716).
On November 17, 1999, the Catholic Bishops of the United States approved The Application of Ex corde Ecclesiae for the United States, implementing the apostolic constitution Ex corde Ecclesiae. This action received the recognitio from the Congregation for Bishops on May 3, 2000. Bishop Joseph A. Fiorenza, President of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB), decreed that the Application would have the force of particular law for the United States on May 3, 2001.
Pope John Paul II's constitution Ex corde Ecclesiae of 1990 fostered a productive dialogue between the Bishops of the United States and the leaders of Catholic colleges and universities. It is anticipated that this recently approved Application of Ex corde Ecclesiae for the United States will further that conversation and build a community of trust and dialogue between Bishops and theologians. Without ongoing and respectful communication, the implementation of the mandatum might appear to be only a juridical constriction of the work of theologians. Both Bishops and theologians are engaged in a necessary though complementary service to the Church that requires ongoing and mutually respectful dialogue.
Article 4, 4, e, iv, of the Application states that "a detailed procedure will be developed outlining the process of requesting and granting (or withdrawing) the mandatum." These guidelines are intended to explain and serve as a resource for the conferral of the mandatum. Only those guidelines herein that repeat a norm of the Application have the force of particular law. They were accepted for distribution to the members of the USCCB on June 15, 2001, by the Conference's general membership.
- Nature of the mandatum.
- The mandatum is fundamentally an acknowledgment by church authority that a Catholic professor of a theological discipline is teaching within the full communion of the Catholic Church (Application: Article 4, 4, e, i).
- The object of the mandatum is the content of the professor's teaching, and thus the mandatum recognizes both the professor's "lawful freedom of inquiry" (Application: Article 2, 2) and the professor's commitment and responsibility to teach authentic Catholic doctrine and to refrain from putting forth as Catholic teaching anything contrary to the Church's magisterium (cf. Application: Article 4, 4, e, iii).
- The mandatum should not be construed as an appointment, authorization, delegation, or approbation of one's teaching by church authorities. Theologians who have received a mandatum are not catechists; they teach in their own name in virtue of their baptism and their academic and professional competence, not in the name of the Bishop or of the Church's magisterium (Application: Article 4, 4, e, ii).
- Who is required to have the mandatum?
- All Catholics who teach Catholic theological disciplines in a Catholic university are required to have a mandatum (canon 812 and Application: Article 4, 4, e).
- In accord with canon 812, the mandatum is an obligation of the professor, not of the university.
- "Teaching" in this context signifies regular presentation (by full-time or part-time professors) of academic material in an academic institution. Occasional lectures as well as preaching and counseling are not within the meaning of the Application and these guidelines.
- "Catholic theological disciplines" in this context signifies Sacred Scripture, dogmatic theology, moral theology, pastoral theology, canon law, liturgy, and church history (cf. canon 252).
- "University" in this context signifies not only institutions that bear the title "university" but also Catholic colleges and other institutions of higher learning.
- Who is to grant the mandatum?
- The mandatum is to be granted by the diocesan Bishop of the diocese in which the Catholic university is located, generally understood to be where the president and central administration offices are located (cf. Application: Article 4, 4, e , iv, ).
- The competent ecclesiastical authority may grant the mandatum personally or through a delegate (Application: Article 4, 4, e, iv, ).
- How is the mandatum to be granted?
- A request for a mandatum by a professor of a Catholic theological discipline should be in writing and should include a declaration that the teacher will teach in full communion with the Church.
- The ecclesiastical authority should respond in writing (Application: Article 4, 4, e, iv, ) (see Appendix for samples).
- An ecclesiastical authority has the right to offer the mandatum on his own initiative (which requires an acceptance), provided that the commitment to teach in full communion with the Church is clear.
- A professor already hired by the effective date (May 3, 2001) of the Application is required to obtain the mandatum by June 1, 2002.
A professor hired after the effective date of the Application is required to obtain the mandatum within the academic year or within six months of the date of being hired, whichever is longer.
If the professor does not obtain the mandatum within the time period given above, the competent ecclesiastical authority should notify the appropriate authority in the college or university.
- Without prejudice to the rights of the diocesan Bishop, a mandatum, once granted, remains in effect wherever and as long as the professor teaches unless and until it is withdrawn by the competent ecclesiastical authority (Application: Article 4, 4, e, iv, ). Although there is no need for the mandatum, once granted, to be granted again by another diocesan Bishop, every diocesan Bishop has the right to require otherwise in his own diocese (Application: footnote 43).
- If the Bishop is contemplating the denial or withdrawal of the mandatum, he should discuss this informally with the theologian, listing the reasons and identifying the sources, and allowing the theologian to make all appropriate responses.
- Grounds and process for withholding or withdrawing the mandatum.
- If all the conditions for granting the mandatum are fulfilled, the professor has a right to receive it and ecclesiastical authority has an obligation in justice to grant it.
- Right intentions and right conduct are to be presumed until the contrary is proven. Hence the ecclesiastical authority should presume, until the contrary is proven, that those who attest that they teach in full communion with the Church actually do so.
- Ecclesiastical authorities who, after discussion with the professor in question, withhold or withdraw the mandatum must state their reasons in writing and otherwise enable the person who believes that his or her rights have been violated to seek recourse (Application: Article 4, 4, e, ; footnote 44). Such withholding or withdrawal should be based on specific and detailed evidence that the teacher does not fulfill the conditions of the mandatum (these Guidelines: 1, b, and c, supra; Application: Article 4, 4, e, iii; NCCB, Doctrinal Responsibilities: Approaches to Promoting Cooperation and Resolving Misunderstandings Between Bishops and Theologians [Washington, D.C.: United States Catholic Conference, 1989], III, C, 4).
- Any negative judgment concerning an objectionable portion of a professor's work should be assessed at three levels: (1) the significance of that portion of the professor's work within the context of his or her overall theological contribution; (2) its relationship to the larger Catholic tradition; (3) its implications for the life of the Church (cf. Doctrinal Responsibilities, III, C, 4).
- Appeals and resolution of disputes.
- Because the decision to withhold or withdraw the mandatum touches on the rights of theologians, the general principles of canon law should be adhered to in seeking recourse and in the process of appeal.
- In the resolution of disputes about the withholding or withdrawal of the mandatum, it is important for both parties to have competent canonical and theological counsel.
- For the resolution of disputes about the withholding or withdrawal of the mandatum, there should be that contact between the Bishop and the professor as urged in canon 1733§1. The process set forth in Doctrinal Responsibilities should be followed. The right of all parties to good reputation must always be honored (cf. canon 220).
- Other means for conflict resolution on the diocesan, regional, or provincial levels (not excluding local mediation procedures) can also be invoked (cf. canon 1733).
- While the use of informal procedures is preferable, the aggrieved party always has the right to formal recourse against the denial or withdrawal of a mandatum in accordance with the canonical norms for "Recourse Against Administrative Decrees" (canons 1732-1739).
- Diocesan Bishops who have Catholic colleges or universities in their dioceses are encouraged to be available to meet with professors of Catholic theological disciplines to review concrete procedures for the granting, withholding, or withdrawal of the mandatum and to discuss other matters of common interest.
- The members of the USCCB Committee for Bishops and Catholic Colleges and University Presidents and its staff will serve as resource personnel for information and guidance on matters connected with the mandatum.
- These guidelines are to be reviewed after five years by a committee appointed by the Conference President.
Sample Mandatum DraftMemorandum
Attestation of the Professor of Catholic Theological Disciplines
I hereby declare my role and responsibility as a professor of a Catholic theological discipline within the full communion of the Church.
As a professor of a Catholic theological discipline, therefore, I am committed to teach authentic Catholic doctrine and to refrain from putting forth as Catholic teaching anything contrary to the Church's magisterium.
Acknowledgment of Diocesan Bishop
I hereby acknowledge your declaration to remain within the full communion of the Catholic Church in fulfillment of your role and responsibility as a teacher of Catholic theological disciplines.
I recognize your commitment as a teacher of Catholic theological disciplines to teach authentic Catholic doctrine and to refrain from putting forth as Catholic teaching anything contrary to the Church's magisterium.
While the mandatum does not constitute you as an agent of the magisterium, it does affirm that your work as a teacher of Catholic theological disciplines is an important part of the Church's mission.
This mandatum remains in effect as long as you are engaged in the teaching of theology or until it is withdrawn by competent ecclesiastical authority for a just cause.
(Offered by the Bishop on His Own Initiative)
||Professor Thomas Bellarmine
||Most Reverend Angelo Buonpastore
This memorandum constitutes the mandatum that you are required to have in order to be in compliance with canon 812. The purpose of the mandatum is to recognize the mutual ecclesial relationship that exists between the Church and teachers of Catholic theology. It also constitutes my grateful response to your participation in the Church's mission.____________________________________________________
I hereby acknowledge your role and responsibility as a teacher of Catholic theology within the full communion of the Catholic Church.
As a teacher of Catholic theology you are committed to teach authentic Catholic doctrine and to refrain from putting forth as Catholic teaching anything contrary to the Church's magisterium.
While this mandatum does not constitute you as an agent of the magisterium, it does affirm that your work as a teacher of theology is an important part of the Church's mission.
This mandatum remains in effect as long as you are engaged in the teaching of Catholic theology or until it is withdrawn by appropriate authority for a just cause.
This mandatum takes effect upon my receipt of the enclosed statement of your understanding and acceptance of its terms.
I, Thomas Bellarmine, have reviewed the mandatum offered to me by Bishop Angelo Buonpastore and, by means of my signature, express my understanding and acceptance of its terms.