WASHINGTON (February 28, 2003) -- A vision for the most inclusive Christian organization ever in the United States advanced dramatically when a diverse group of 46 national church leaders agreed January 29 on a concrete proposal to take back to their church bodies for consideration.
The proposal-for what is provisionally called Christian Churches Together in the U.S.A. (CCT)- builds on more than two years of behind-the-scenes work by church leaders. Agreement on the proposal signifies that "we have moved from the phase of visioning to begin implementation," said the Rev. Wesley Granberg-Michaelson, who is general secretary of the Reformed Church in America and who currently chairs CCT's steering committee.
Over the next few years, the proposal will be placed before the top decision-making bodies of many denominations (or communions as some bodies are called) and other Christian organizations, as their regularly scheduled assemblies take place. The proposal calls for a fellowship that is committed "to grow closer together in Christ" in order to strengthen its "Christian witness in the world."
Granberg-Michaelson reported that the 46 church leaders, who met on the campus of Fuller Theological Seminary, in Pasadena, Calif., also agreed that implementation "would require at least 25 denominations or communions to say 'yes,'" They further agreed that the new organization "would not be inaugurated until the numbers reflect the diversity of the Christian families present at the meeting," Granberg-Michaelson said. "Having a mix is the whole point."
Church leaders who participated in the Jan. 27-29 Pasadena meeting represented five families within Christianity that the proposal describes as "Evangelical/Pentecostal, Historic Protestant, Orthodox, Racial/Ethnic (for example, predominantly African American churches), and Roman Catholic."
The Catholic Church was represented at the meeting by His Eminence William Cardinal Keeler, Archbishop of Baltimore; Bishop Tod D. Brown of Orange; Rev. Ronald G. Roberson, CSP, Associate Director of the Secretariat for Ecumenical and Interreligious Affairs at the USCCB; Sr. Joan McGuire, OP, Director of the Office for Ecumenical and Interreligious Affairs of the Archdiocese of Chicago; Sr. Joan Delaney, MM, former representative of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity to the Mission and Evangelism office of the World Council of Churches; Rev. Rafael Luevano, Ecumenical Officer of the Diocese of Orange; and Deacon Thomas McGowan, former Ecumenical Officer of the Diocese of Oakland. Rev. Arthur Kennedy, Executive Director of the SEIA, represented Bishop Stephen Blaire of Stockton, the Chairman of the Bishops' Committee for Ecumenical and Interreligious Affairs, who was unable to attend.
Representatives of at least ten churches that belong to the National Association of Evangelicals attended the meeting, and the Southern Baptist Convention sent an observer. Also among those present were participants from thirteen Protestant and five Orthodox churches that also hold membership in the National Council of Churches. The degree to which CCT and the NCC duplicate functions is a question for "discernment" by the NCC's 36 member communions over the next few years, Granberg-Michaelson said.
Given the breadth of the group at Pasadena, which he described as "expanded significantly" from the last meeting, April 2002, in Chicago, Granberg-Michaelson said that any agreement "was an open question going in."
"We were not at all sure we would have something to circulate, and it was an inspirational moment when we decided to do that," he said.
In the next few weeks, members of the steering committee will invite still other denominations and Christian organizations to join the CCT process. The committee hopes to draw an even broader group of participants to the next planning meeting, projected for late 2003 or early 2004.
"CCT is the best chance that we will have in this decade to really change the ecumenical landscape and to create a body that more fully reflects the life of the churches in the United States," Granberg-Michaelson concluded. "It could be a very powerful tool for the mission of the church."
Cardinal Keeler said it was clear at this meeting that the concerns that had been raised by various participants were met in a practical way. "Now it is up to the various churches to study whether they wish to enter into discussions to further refine what needs to be done," he said. "Please God, we are moving towards creating an instrument that will help make more visible the spiritual bonds among Christians in the United States."
From a Catholic perspective, this initiative parallels developments that have been taking place around the world, especially in other English-speaking countries. The Catholic Church is already a member of similar organizations in such places as the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, and the Caribbean. The 1993 Directory for the Application of Principles and Norms on Ecumenism (nos. 163-171)issued by the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity addresses ways in which the Catholic Church can participate in ecumenical organizations on the national and regional levels. Cardinal Keeler commented that when he has attended meeting of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity in the Vatican, "I have been struck by the number of bishops who tell me that their churches have a role in national or regional ecumenical organizations."
For his part, Pope John Paul II has strongly encouraged such ecumenical initiatives since the beginning of his pontificate. When he addressed the members of the Working Group of Christian Churches in Switzerland in 1984, the Pope said that in view of the growing secularization of society,
a great historical responsibility lies before us, regarding which no Christian community can remain isolated unto itself, but is called to the highest possible measure of common witness for the Gospel in all areas of life. As disciples of the one Lord, Jesus Christ, we have an obligation, founded on Holy Scripture and on the early creeds, our common heritage, to follow this call according to the best counsels of conscience…Addressing an ecumenical group of Christians in Toronto, Ontario, on September 14, 1984, the Pope said:
Ecumenical collaboration, as we have discovered, can take many forms: working together in projects of fraternal service, engaging in theological dialogue and joint ventures to understand our troubled past, cooperative actions for justice and the humanizing of the technological society, and many others. All of these are of great value and need to be continued in earnest, especially those which help promote the truth and help us grow in fraternal charity.In 1995 Pope John Paul II spelled out the ecumenical vision of the Catholic Church in his encyclical, Ut Unum Sint. He spoke of the rediscovered brotherhood among Christians as a fruit of the contemporary ecumenical movement (nos. 41-42), and affirmed that the quest for unity among Christians "is not something added on, but stands at the very heart of Christ's mission. Nor is it some secondary attribute of the community of his disciples. Rather, it belongs to the very essence of this community" (n. 9).
At the General Audience in the Vatican on January 22, 2003, the Holy Father surveyed the current ecumenical situation in these hopeful words:
Looking at the whole ecumenical scene, I feel duty bound to thank the Lord for the distance traveled till now, both for the quality of the fraternal relations knitted among the different communities and for the results of the theological dialogues, even if they are different in their methods and levels. We can say that today Christians are more close-knit and solidary, even if the road towards unity continues to be uphill with its obstacles and bottlenecks. Following the path indicated by the Lord, they advance with confidence, because they know that they are accompanied by the Risen Lord, as the disciples of Emmaus, toward the goal of full ecclesial communion that actually leads to the common "breaking of the Bread."Full text of the CCT proposal and list of participants follows:
Christian Churches Together in the U.S.A.
I. Preamble
All who share the theological affirmations and purpose are eligible to participate in Christian Churches Together. Bishop Vicken Aykazian Diocese of the Armenian Church of Participant Commissioner W. Todd Bassett The Salvation Army Participant Mr. John Briscoe NCCC Participant Bishop Tod Brown Diocese of Participant Ms. Sharon Browning Sharon Browning and Associates Participant Rev. David Caudle Church of the Nazarene Participant Rev. Rothangliani Chhangte Participant Rev. Dr. Seung Koo Choi Korean Presbyterian Church in Participant Mr. Bonn Clayton Nat'l Assoc. of Congregational Christ. Churches Participant Right Rev. Dimitrios Couchell Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of Participant Sister Joan Delaney Roman Catholic Church Participant Dr. Barrett Duke Southern Baptist Convention Observer Rev. Dr. Robert Edgar NCCC Participant Bishop Perry Engle Brethren
in Participant Rev. Dr. David Engelhard Christian Reformed Church Participant Rev. Jon S. Enslin Participant Dr. Thomas Episcopal Participant Dr. Michael Gillis Antiochian Orthodox Christian Archdiocese Participant Rev. Wesley Granberg-
Michaelson Reformed Church in Participant Bishop Sang-Ehil Han Participant Bishop Roger Haskins Bd. Of Bishops - Free Participant Rev. Dr. Roberta Hestenes World Vision Participant Ms. Elenie Huszagh NCCC Participant Friend Thomas Jeavons Religious Society of Friends Participant Archbishop Cyril Aphrem Karim Syrian Orthodox Church Participant Cardinal William H. Keeler Archdiocese of Participant Rev. Arthur Kennedy Participant Kirkpatrick Presbyterian Church (U.S.A) Participant Very Rev. Leonid Kishkovsky Orthodox Church in Participant Bishop James Leggett Participant Rev. Michael E. Int'l Council of Community Churches Participant Dr. Howard Loewen Fuller Theological Seminary Participant Rev. Rafael Luevano Participant Dr. Kevin Mannoia Dean of Observer Scott E. McBride Int'l. Church of the Foursquare Gospel Participant Ms. Retha McCutchen Friends United Meeting Participant Rev. Thomas McGowan Diocese of Participant Sister Joan McGuire Archdiocese of Participant Bishop George St. Stephen's Participant Very Rev. Dr. Michel Najim Antiochian Orthodox Christian Archdiocese Participant Commissioner Philip The Salvation Army Participant Rev. Rodney Parrott Disciples Seminary Foundation Participant President Glenn K. Palmberg The Participant Rev. Judy Mills Reimer Participant Mr. Claude Rhea, III North American Observer Dr. Ann K. Riggs Nat'l Council of Churches of Christ in the Participant Rev. Ronald Roberson Participant Rev. Dr. William G. Rusch Comm. On Faith & Order Observer Rev. Gabriel A. Salguero Missionary Pentecostal Churches of God, Inc. Observer Rev. Dr. Robert Sawyer Participant Rev. James Schrag Participant Rev. Ronald J. Sider Evangelicals for Social Action Participant Bishop Melvin G. Talbert United Participant Dr. Joseph Tkach Worldwide Participant Rev. Lydia Veliko United Participant Mr. David Wagschal Orthodox Church in Participant Rev. Jim Wallis Sojourners/Call to Renewal Participant Rev. Robina Winbush Presbyterian Church Participant
We are challenged as Christians by the prayer of Jesus in John 17 that all who believe in Him might be one with God and with one another so that the world would believe in Him as God and Savior.
We acknowledge that this is not what we experience now and recognize that we have different histories and convictions on some key issues.
We pray for a fresh awareness of the Holy Spirit's work among us that will foster:
We believe that we will be led into these new relationships as we commit ourselves to spiritual disciplines such as prayer and study of Scripture to listen for and obey the voice of Christ.
This leads us to establish Christian Churches Together in the U.S.A. to create new levels of relationships and actions that offer a shared witness for Christ to the world.
II. Theological Affirmations
Christian Churches Together in the USA welcomes churches, Christian communities, and national Christian organizations that:
III. Purpose and Activity
The purpose of Christian Churches Together is to enable churches and national Christian organizations to grow closer together in Christ in order to strengthen our Christian witness in the world. Participants in Christian Churches Together accomplish this purpose by:
We cannot act together until we pray and walk together and understand each other better. Therefore in the early period, our primary focus should be on the first four activities. As we do this faithfully, we believe the Holy Spirit will lead us to discern how best to engage in the three remaining activities in our Christian witness to the world.
At least once a year, a General Assembly will gather for two and a half days for fellowship, prayer, theological discussion and discernment of potential areas for common witness.
Christian Churches Together will sponsor in the name of Christian Churches Together, various Forums on diverse topics (e.g., evangelism, worship, public policy). The Steering Committee will have full authority over the topics and the program (speakers, etc.) for Forums sponsored by Christian Churches Together. National Christian organizations that share Christian Churches Together's purpose and theology will be invited to participate in these Forums.
IV. Participation in Christian Churches Together
There will be two categories of participants:
No more than approximately 20% of Christian Churches Together will be participant national Christian organizations.
The Christian Churches Together Steering Committee will develop a broad invitation list of national church bodies, associations of churches and national Christian organizations, which will be invited to become participants in Christian Churches Together as it is founded. Participant national Christian organizations will be those that strongly share the theological convictions and purposes of Christian Churches Together, are deeply related to its churches, and which have the strong support of a wide variety of churches that will compose Christian Churches Together.
Once inaugurated, and Phase II has begun, Christian Churches Together will develop a process for issuing additional invitations for participation and for receiving applications from those churches and national Christian organizations wishing to participate. Criteria will be developed to welcome into the fellowship those national church bodies, associations of churches and national Christian organizations, which, based on the discernment of the governing bodies of Christian Churches Together, will uphold its theological affirmations, further its purpose, and promote unity within the fellowship of Christian Churches Together.
All participants in Christian Churches Together will be expected to:
Those organizations that meet the criteria for participation, but are not able to do so at this time, will be invited to be observers in the meetings and gatherings of Christian Churches Together.
V. Governing Christian Churches Together
1.) General Assembly
The General Assembly (meeting at least once every year for two and a half days) will consist of the heads of communions (or their designated representative) of each participating church plus an additional representative for each five million members (or fraction thereof) in their church or association of churches. Twenty per cent may also be heads of participant national Christian organizations.
For a small part of the annual meeting, the heads of participant churches and participant national Christian organizations will meet to decide upon basic issues-- including at least: the addition of new participants, foundational theological documents, and Christian Churches Together's constitution.
2. Steering Committee
The Steering Committee will consist of 18-24 members. Each of Christian Churches Together's five families (Evangelical/Pentecostal; Historic Protestant; Historic Racial/Ethnic; Orthodox; Roman Catholic) will have three members each on the Steering Committee. Each of the five families will choose their three representatives according to their own procedures. The Steering Committee will have at least three additional at-large members. These at-large members may be representatives of participant national Christian organizations (selected according to criteria to be developed by the Steering Committee).
Upon joining Christian Churches Together, each communion or association of churches will choose which of the five families they wish to join for purposes of selecting the members of the Steering Committee.
The Steering Committee will elect its officers, develop bylaws (including length of term on the Steering Committee), and attend to the business of Christian Churches Together between meetings of the General Assembly.
3. Topical Forums
Any action (declarations, policy proposals, etc.) that develop out of the Forums sponsored by Christian Churches Together will be done, not in the name of Christian Churches Together, but in the name of whatever churches, national Christian organizations and individuals choose to sign on to that specific item. Common action in the name of Christian Churches Together can only be done by consensus of the General Assembly or Steering Committee.
4. Consensus Decision Making
Decisions in every setting of Christian Churches Together's life will be by consensus. Only when all members present either say "Yes" or agree to "stand aside" will the body move ahead on any action. For every decision, representatives from each of the five families must be present.
A consensus decision-making process emphasizes the process of listening and discussion and is not merely a matter of saying yes or no. Several responses to any proposal are possible in consensus decision-making:
VI. Finances and Budget
1. During phase I
Each year, $20,000 should be raised to cover the costs of the Steering Committee. Churches and organizations exploring participation should contribute at least $100 annually and where possible $1000 or more.
2. During phase II
We will need to create an equitable formula which should include one or more of the following factors:
VII. Time Line
1. During Phase I
2. During Phase II
NOTE: This document was approved by consensus by the participants at the January 27-29, 2003 meeting at Fuller Theological Seminary, Pasadena, California. See the Appendix for the list of participants.
(January 27-29, 2003 Meeting of Christian Churches Together)

![[home]](/comm/images/usccb_logo.gif)